BBC Horizon documentary about our relationship with tiny little tablets of crushed powder that seem to have magical properties.
It also says a lot about our society’s magical belief in the power of Doctors and scientists to fix everything that troubles us.
This is a revealing that story casts the spotlight on the multi-billion dollar industry clothes itself in the language of science yet remains , at its core, an accidental process. Medications are typically discovered and brought to market less by deliberate design than by accidental discovery: so that, only when we all become part of the experiment, can we find out what they really do for us – and whether that is worth the risk.
This is not an anti drug movie, it simply lays out how it is that we find new drugs, try them out and then find out how they really work.
We get to hear from doctors talking about balancing risks and benefit; from scientists who spend their days searching for a match between complaints people have and the millions of secret compounds contained in that temple to modern science that is the massive, robot drug factory – the chemical compound library of a major drug company;
We even get to meet the scientist who devised the robot penis simulator used to test the hypothesis that one drug -UK92,480 – that was failing dismally in trials as a heart medicine yet seemed to have another upstanding side effect – and went on to become the world’s best-selling medicine, dispensed at a rate of six every second.
It also opens a window onto how medicine conceives of the problems people report, categorises them as chemical problems then reduces then to the task finding the magic compound in vast libraries of chemicals that are both potential killers and potential blockbuster drug.
Watching it might open your eyes about how little you know – and about how little doctors and other experts know too.
It might also help you believe a little less in the magical properties of medicines and magical powers of Doctors – and prompt you to take a more of an active interest in the drugs you might take or me offered by your Doc.
Over the course of your lifetime you are likely to be prescribed more than 14,000 pills.
– pills that will possibly save and extend your life by decades, or shorten it, even or kill you.
Science or Serendipity?
- “The accidental nature of drug discovery means that little is known about what pills will do until we all take them.
- “In many ways you learn as much about your new medicine after it’s launched than you ever knew before”
The Faustian bargain in your medicine cabinet
The somewhat one-sided bargain we enter into when we take a pill…
- “When you take a tablet you are entering into a bargain:
- …our side of the deal is that we honestly believe that the tablet will do you more good than harm
- …but you have to accept the very real possibility that in the long-term it may do you more harm than good. We just don’t know that yet”
The experimental nature of medicine[s]
“in the 1950s depression was a strictly private affair – those that sought help got little in return. Those drugs that were on offer were unlikely to lift your spirits.
“It all changed when a new wave of drugs came along… Suddenly deprtession had become a treatable condition and that made it more socially acceptable. By the 1990s the number of people coming forward seeking treatment tripled.
“Soon SSRIs were seen as a solution to everything.
“Back in those days if you came into a GP’s surgery looking a little bit glum because someone had stolen your bike or your dog had died you’d be assessed as being depressed and given antidepressants”
“WAY overkill . Everyone now admits that was true”
“In time the tide began to turn against SSRIs. As more and more people took them some disturbing side effects began to emerge.
“The risks are that approximately…
- 1 in 5 people will become much more anxious on these drugs
- 1 in 100 will go on to a suicidal act
- 1 in 500 to 600 may go on to complete suicide who wouldn’t have done so if they hadn’t been on these pills
“The makers of the controversial antidepressant drug Seroxat have been criticised by the [UK] healthcare regulatory body for withholding information about the risk of suicidal behaviours associated with the drug.”
“In 2006 GSK the makers of Seroxat admitted that it increased the rate of suicide eight times.
Sadly side effects from drugs are nothing new…
“The greats drugs disaster of the post-war era. Given to expectant mothers with morning sickness in the late 1950s, it was not long before its devastating side effect became clear.
“Thalidomide was withdrawn in 1961 and brought with it new drug trials procedures that were supposed to prevent anything like it happening again.
…but they haven’t.
“In the past five years, in the UK alone, eight drugs have been withdrawn from the market by regulators.
Drugs for Arthritis
“There are warnings that a drug used worldwide by millions of people with arthritis can increase the risk of heart attack.
“the benefits no longer outweigh the considerable risks.
“the anti-obesity rug rimonobant was banned because it could cause suicide.
Used to treat rheumatoid arthritis and menstrual pain was withdrawn after it caused 140,000 heart attacks in five years.
All drugs are experimental
“The discovery of undesired side effects is, however, intrinsic to the experimental nature of medicine.
“Clinical trials are done on thousands of people. Bit some side effects are only discovered when hundreds of thousands of people take them when the drug comes to market.
“There is no such thing as a totally safe medicine.
“There’s no such thing as a medicine that we know absolutely everything about”
“The question is…
‘what risks are you prepared to take, for what benefits?’
“Side effects are not restricted to the dangers written on the back of the packets.
“The thing that set out to become the solution has become the problem itself.
“Codeine tablets don’t contain enough to give additional pain relief but there is enough to get you hooked. “These used to be my best friends, they’re not now, I hate ’em”.
If I could invent a pill…
“Despite how dangerous pills can be, we still love them…
“If I would invent any pill it would cure everything and would be called…
Statins, Pills and “Normal”
Drugs now don’t just target specific organisms-in the way an antibiotic targets an infectious organism – they are used to treat ng risk factors in populations: blanket prescriptions that are assessed less by the effects they have directly on you and your life, but upon risks across an entire population.
If you’ve got a drug that’s designed to treat not sick people, but “everybody”, a pill that everybody ” needs to take, that ey treat must be a dream come true.
There are huge number of people using these pills whose lipid levels come down but they experience a series of problems caused by the drugs.
We may be faced with a choice – a shorter life or a longer one that’s not as much fun.
“We’ve moved from is a world in which we thought that drugs were poisons and the art of medicine was to make sure that the person had a reasonable serious condition that posed risks justified the risks that we knew came with the pills. …to a world where the drugs are now viewed as fertilizers, they can do no harm if we just spread them around the place – widely.
Getting real about drugs
Drugs have the power to save and to ease lives. We will discover new drugs, and new uses for old ones. But there is no escaping the truth:
- Show me a drug with no side effects and I’ll show you a drug with no benefits
- The difference between a drug and a poison, is basically the dose
- We’re all part of one big clinical trial, every patient who takes a drug is part of an experiment to see whether that drug is safe to use or not in the long-term.
“I’ve spent my entire career prescribing medicines of one sort or another to patients of every kind. I honestly believe that for eth majority of those patients, we’ve done more good than harm.
Pill Poppers : BBC Horizon
http://www.disclose.tv/embed/147392<p><a href=”http://www.disclose.tv” title=”Weird News – Odd Videos”>Disclose.tv</a> – <a href=”http://www.disclose.tv/action/viewvideo/147392/Pill_Poppers_BBC_Documentary/”>Pill Poppers (BBC Documentary)</a></p>
You must be logged in to post a comment.